When the wife and I first started dating I was going through my divorce from my ex still. We dated for around 3 months when suddenly, (we will call her Anne) messaged me and said she needed a break to “figure out what she wanted”.
Free cuckold community
Sign up now!
It was a long hard week as I tried my best to give her space and let her make her decision about whether she still wanted to continue. After almost a week, she hit me up and said she loved me and wanted to be with me. She came over and we had amazing sex. She seemed super turned on and wet for me and I was more than happy to eat her pussy and fuck her.
Fast forward several months, we are driving down the road and I had been having a feeling she hadn’t been telling me everything. She had told me that she hadn’t seen anyone and she had just spent some time alone during the week apart. I started prying and she broke down and told me she had gone on a date with a guy she knew from high school and they had gone to dinner but that was it. I knew there was probably more but didn’t want to pressure her and was already upset she had lied to me. She told me her best friend had told her not to tell me since I would be mad so I left it alone. We moved past it and a couple years later, Anne and I got engaged.
We were again driving down the road and I brought it up. Told her I didn’t believe it had been just a date and if it wasn’t, I wouldn’t be mad. She finally admitted she had seen him a couple times and had gone back to his place and they had fucked. She spent the night and claimed when she woke up, she realized she wanted to be with me and called me.
Later I realized that was the morning she came home and we fucked and I remembered how wet she had been. She claimed half heartedly that he wore a condom but based on what I know about her past and with me, he most likely fucked her all night bare and blew his load in her and then she decided she wanted me more.
It doesn’t bother me anymore but it was a bit difficult to reconcile at first but it turned into me wanting to see her with other guys and sharing her over time.