Our best friend, Greg, had a birthday coming up and I knew that Nicole would want to do something special sexually for him so I was expecting her to bring it up to me. It was about a week before his birthday when she asked.
Free cuckold community
Sign up now!
“Are we still going out for dinner with Greg on Friday for his birthday?” she asked me.
“Yep,” I replied. “Got reservations at the Steakhouse.”
Greg’s birthday was actually during the week, but we decided to go out on Friday instead.
“I know Greg and I already had our monthly weekend together, but how do you feel about me spending Saturday with him?” She asked. “It doesn’t have to be the whole weekend. I know our agreement and I’m not trying to change it, but I thought it would be nice to give him some sexy alone time for his birthday. If you’re uncomfortable with it I understand and we’ll just stick to what we’re doing.”
“I’m not against you spending Saturday with him,” I replied. “I think a birthday can be an exception.”
“Thank you,” she smiled. “I wanted to do something special. There’s a piece of what I want to do that can be a gift from you too. Do you want to know what I’m thinking?”
“Let’s hear it.”
My suspicion was that I’d be giving Nicole to Greg as a gift and she pretty much confirmed that in some of the details she told me. She was still secretive about the other aspects and said she wanted to make sure it was a surprise for Greg.
Friday came and we picked up Greg and took him out for dinner.
The restaurant was fairly busy on a Friday night but we managed to get a nice booth for the three of us. Nicole sat beside Greg and I sat across from them.
The food was fantastic and helped me take my mind off Nicole heavily flirting with Greg. She was doing it so much that the waiter and I’m sure anyone else watching assumed they were the couple.
I scanned around the room numerous times to make sure I didn’t see anyone we knew. Nicole knows I’m very protective of our arrangement and I’m uncomfortable with any public displays from them.
Halfway through the meal I saw Nicole jerk her body and stifle a little gasp. I could see Greg’s hand was between her legs and no doubt up her dress.
“How about we not do that here,” I suggested dryly.
“Sorry,” Greg and Nicole said quietly while she adjusted her dress. “Got carried away.”
They soon got back to flirting but at least they weren’t openly groping each other for the rest of the dinner. They saved that for the car ride back.
After dinner the three of us hopped in the car and headed back to my place to hang out for a while and for Nicole to give Greg his “present.” The whole way home I got to watch the two of them grope and make out with each other from the rearview mirror. I was starting to feel better about the evening, watching them like this in private was fun.
When we finally arrived and I got out of the car I got to see Nicole pull her dress back into place which was apparently bunched around her waist for most of the trip home.
The three of us went inside for drinks and sat around and talked for a while. Nicole sat beside Greg and the two of them continued to flirt and lightly touch each other but all in all it wasn’t overly sexual.
It was almost midnight when Nicole got up to make her announcement.
“I think it's time that Mike and I give you your present,” she said standing in the middle of the room in front of Greg.
She motioned me over so I could do the part she ran by me earlier in the week. I stepped behind my girlfriend and unzipped her dress, sliding it off her shoulders and letting it fall to the floor. She carefully stepped out of it and let me put it aside.
Nicole wasn’t wearing a bra so she was dressed only in her panties and heels. She turned her head and smiled at me, encouraging me to finish what I was supposed to do.
I hooked my fingers in her panties and started sliding them down her legs, as I bent down I noticed for the first time that Nicole had a butt plug in. I had never seen her use one before and in fact I didn’t even know she owned one.
The silver plug with a bright red jewel was right in my face as I knelt behind her and helped my girlfriend step out of her panties. I could feel my jealousy build as it seemed to be one more thing she did for Greg that she didn’t for me. Still I was able to keep it in check, I wanted Greg to have a good time tonight with Nicole so I pushed the feelings down.
“I bought something special for tonight,” she told Greg and playfully turned around. “I wanted to make sure I was ready for you.”
Nicole bent over at the waist, reached back and spread her ass for Greg.
“Do you like it?” she teased, looking back over her shoulder at him.
“Fuck yeah,” he laughed. I could tell Greg looked very pleased at what Nicole was offering him.
“Mike? Did you have something else to say?” she said, taking my hand as we both straightened up and stood beside each other.
“Happy Birthday Greg,” I smiled, hopefully convincingly, but now slightly annoyed at the plug. “I’d like you to have Nicole for your birthday present, she’s all yours until Sunday. You two are more than welcome to fuck as much as you’d like. In fact I’d love it if you would.”
I knew the routine by now, they both liked to hear me say it. I liked it too so it was just a fun thing we did before she spent time with him.
“There’s more,” she smiled. “As you know, Mike’s birthday is about seven months away and as the next part of your gift I’ve decided that until then my ass is for your use only.”
This was unexpected and I was definitely caught off guard. Nicole and I had briefly talked about playing with denial or maybe letting Greg or someone else do things I couldn’t, but as far as I was concerned it was still just hypothetical and I wasn’t sure how I actually felt about it.
Nicole obviously felt this was something I was okay with and needed a push like she had done with some other things like eating her creampie. Maybe she was right but I still think I would have liked to know it was coming or at least agreed that it’s something I wanted to try.
The surprise announcement felt like a gut punch. I felt like she wasn’t really following our rules and dumping this on me. I know I had a veto and could say no, but doing it like this felt like I was being pressured into accepting it and not making a scene on Greg’s birthday. I decided to allow things for tonight, but we would need to talk about this afterwards.
My girlfriend curled up on Greg’s lap and she gave him a soft kiss and wished him a happy birthday.
His hand quickly moved between her legs and she gave out a quiet gasp and giggle as he teased her clit.
“I’m all naked and wet for you but I think we still need to make sure you’re ready,” Nicole teased Greg.
I wasn’t sure if Nicole wanted me to suck his dick, or hold her legs open for him while they fuck or whatever, but I really wasn’t feeling it at this point and decided to duck out before things got awkward. The way they acted at dinner, the butt plug and unexpected denial announcement really took me out of the partying mood. Greg didn’t seem to notice I was annoyed and I just wanted him to have fun tonight and not spoil things for him.
“You two enjoy yourself,” I said, grabbing Nicole’s keys from the table. “I’ll be at her place tonight to give you some privacy.”
It was Nicole’s turn to be caught off guard and she wasn’t expecting this reaction from me at all. I think she assumed I’d watch and help her fuck Greg then the two of them would go over to his place or wherever the next day. They could still do whatever they wanted tomorrow, but I wasn’t really in the mood for watching them tonight.
“Happy Birthday buddy,” I smiled and waved goodbye and excused myself. “Have fun tonight, try not to wake the neighbors.”
“Thanks,” he laughed. “We’ll try to keep it down.”
She hopped off Greg’s lap and ran to the door before I could leave.
“What’s going on? Are you okay?” Nicole asked, I could tell she was totally confused and quickly becoming concerned that she fucked up and pushed things too far tonight.
“I’m just not feeling it right now,” I replied quietly so Greg wouldn’t hear. “But we agreed this is Greg’s time. I want you two to have fun.”
“Are you sure?”
“I’m sure.”
“Okay,” she said, giving an uncertain smile. “I’ll see you on Sunday then.”
I gave her a kiss goodbye and left for her apartment.
I flopped down on her bed as soon as I arrived. I was tired and annoyed. I wasn’t angry with her, that quickly passed. The denial of her ass was actually somewhat appealing to me the more I thought about it. Finally being able to get her ass on my birthday after months of saying no might be fun. Maybe she could tease me about how I’m not allowed to have it while I was fucking her. My cock was getting hard thinking about our future play times. I didn’t like how things went tonight, but I knew we’d be okay after we talked about it on Sunday. The two of us had been communicating a lot better lately so this was just a small setback.
One thing I still didn’t like was the butt plug. When it came to sex it was one more thing that she thought to do for him before me. It was a sore point between us and something Nicole had tried to be more thoughtful about. Sometimes the jealousy was good and made our sex incredible, sometimes not so much.
I decided to worry about it later and fell asleep dreaming of Greg fucking my girlfriend in the ass.
It was almost noon before I got up and noticed a few texts on my phone that were sent about a half hour apart.
Nicole: Hey Babe, we’re going out for a bit then probably spending the night at Greg’s place if that’s okay. You can come back home if you like, we won’t be there if you need some alone time or don’t want to see us. I was thinking about you all night and I’m really sorry that you felt you needed to leave. I didn’t mean for things to go that way. That wasn’t my plan at all. I can cancel tonight if you’d like, just let me know.
Nicole: Call or text me if you need to talk okay? I really thought you’d be okay with everything last night. I was trying to tease both of you and do something special but completely misread that you weren’t enjoying it. It’s completely my fault. I’m really sorry if I upset you and ruined your night. I wish I realized it sooner.
Nicole: Just give me a quick call or text when you can so I know you’re okay. I can’t stop thinking about you.
Me: Hey Nic. I’m okay. Heading back to my place soon. Hope to see you on Sunday.
Nicole answered almost immediately.
Nicole: Thanks for replying. Having lunch then maybe some mini-golf or a movie with Greg. I’m all yours on Sunday. I promise. Do you want me to cut today short?
Me: No. Enjoy your day. I’m fine. We have tomorrow. Love you.
Nicole: Love you too
I hung around her apartment for a while but I prefer my place so I headed home. The rest of the day was pretty boring. I of course thought about what Nicole and Greg were up to. I’m sure they were hanging out and having fun and of course I'm sure she let him fuck her ass. That was basically a given since that was her gift to him. I jerked off a couple times thinking of Greg plowing my girlfriend's ass but mostly just watched TV or did some work around the house.
It was early Sunday morning when I felt Nicole slip into bed with me.
“Good morning baby,” she purred and kissed me.
“Hey,” I sleepily replied and pulled her close to cuddle with me.
“Are you still mad at me?” she asked. “I misread you all fucking night. I’m so sorry.”
“I’ll get over it,” I replied. “We’re good.”
“We don’t have to do the seven months,” she told me. “I just thought that my announcement would be a fun cuckold thing that both you and Greg would get a kick out of. I’m sorry I didn’t talk to you about it first. I just made some dumb assumptions. If you ever want my butt, just say so.”
I squeezed Nicole tight.
“Thank you,” I said. “But you know, for now I think I’d like it if you’d say no when I ask.”
“Really?” Nicole said, sitting up.
“Yeah,” I replied. “Let’s try it out for a bit. If I change my mind I’ll bring it up outside the bedroom and use our safeword so you know I’m serious, but I want you to say no for now.”
“Okay, I can do that,” she replied. “As long as it’s what you want.”
“I don’t know if it’s what I want, but I think I’d like to try.”
We were both quiet for a moment.
“What about the butt plug?” she asked.
“What about it?”
“You don’t like it, do you?”
“No,” I told her. “When it comes to sex you have a history of doing things for him first.”
“I know,” she sighed. “I was trying to make the butt thing even more special for the two of you. I know it looks like I bought it for Greg, but honestly it was just as much for you. Like I said, I wanted that night to be a really fun cuckold night for both of you and thought that would be a cool accessory to top it all off. After I thought about it I realized how it probably looked to you.”
“Do you still have it,” I asked as my hand rubbed her butt.
“No,” she replied. “I left it at Greg’s. I wasn’t sure how you felt about it. Do you want me to wear it for you? Or get rid of it? I’m fine either way.”
“No,” I told her. “Keep it with Greg. That can be a you and him thing too.”
“Okay,” she frowned. “Sorry for fucking that up too.”
“It’s okay, I understand what you were trying to do. I just don't want to see it right now. Did you at least have fun and have lots of sex yesterday?”
“Yes,” she laughed, her mood improving. “Do you want to hear about it?”
“You know I do,” I replied.
Nicole shrieked as I rolled on top of her and quickly moved my cock to her pussy.
“Fuck me,” she demanded.
I slowly pushed my cock into her and while she was wet, it wasn’t the sloppy seconds wet that I was used to.
“When did you last fuck Greg?” I asked as I started to thrust. "Last night?"
“No, just before I came over,” she moaned. “He fucked me in the ass before he let me shower. That's why you can't feel him in me.”
“How many times did he do it? Fuck your ass.”
“Three,” she panted as I picked up speed. “He did it right after you left, he bent me over your favorite chair and came in my ass. Then he did it again the next night at his place, then this morning before I came over.”
“Did you like it?”
“I loved every minute,” she gasped as I slammed into her. “Oh, baby, I was such a slut for him. Just like you want me to. I let him take me in every way.”
“I want your ass too,” I growled.
“No baby, it’s not for you. Only Greg. You can share my pussy with him.”
I kept pounding into Nicole and I could feel her orgasm building along with my own.
“Did you wear the plug for him?”
“Yes,” she gasped, getting close to orgasm. “He made me bend over and slipped it in before we went out. I wore it all day and he only took it out to fuck my ass again.”
“What about next time you see him,” I asked. “Will you wear it again?”
“God I hope so,” she cried. “I want him to play with my ass whenever he wants.”
“I’m cumming,” I warned Nicole.
“Me too baby, cum in me,” she begged.
I erupted inside her just as she came and we stayed locked like that for what seemed like forever. Finally I rolled off Nicole and she cuddled up next to me.
“Are you sure you’re okay?” she asked. “I wanted to surprise you and make this weekend special for you too. I didn't mean to upset you. I wanted to tease you at dinner by playing around with Greg, but that seemed to piss you off, then I thought you were okay and liked watching Greg and me playing in the car so I thought everything was good again, but then I fucked it all up with the butt stuff.”
“I’m good and we’re good,” I told her. “I didn’t like how it happened at the time, but I like where we are now and I know you meant well.”
“I love you,” she said and kissed me. “Next time will be better for you. I promise.”