Free cuckold community
Sign up now!
Really Was No Decision
I sat on the closed toilet lid in the bathroom, the cool tile under my bare feet grounding me as I stared into the mirror. The fluorescent light overhead was unforgiving, casting sharp shadows across my naked body. I studied myself the way I had never really allowed before. Short, yes. Doughy around the middle, soft where other men carried muscle. My chest was smooth, no definition, just gentle curves that sloped down to a belly that hung slightly over my waistband when I wore anything tight. My arms lacked bulk, my thighs touched when I walked. But my ass… it was rounder than it should be for a man, fuller, with a natural lift that made the cheeks look plump even without effort. My dick, average in length and girth, actually looked bigger on my compact frame, nestled in a modest patch of dark hair. The hair on my head was thick and bushy, dark waves that fell just past my ears. I was decent. Pleasant, even. Pretty? But undeniably soft. Undeniably not built like Mark.
Behind me, hanging on the hook by the towel rack, was the short pink nightgown Cindi had laid out earlier. Satin, delicate, the kind of thing that shimmered under light and clung to every curve. It was unmistakably feminine. If I put it on, there would be no pretending anymore. No going back to the version of myself I had spent years building. The cuckold thing I could handle. I had accepted that months ago. I liked watching my wife get taken by a stronger man. I liked being dominated, degraded, used. I liked the way it made me feel small and safe at the same time. I could always stop that if it ever stopped being fun. But this… this was different. This was permanent. Once I crossed that line, once I let myself be penetrated, once I let my body learn what it felt like to be filled and claimed like that, I knew I would crave it forever. I was already craving it. The thought alone kept me half-hard, even now.
Cindi knocked softly on the door. “Did you put it on yet?”
“Not yet,” I called back, voice quieter than I intended.
Silence for a moment. Then, “Okay. Take your time.”
I thought about walking out right then. Leaving the nightgown hanging there, slipping into my jeans and T-shirt, kissing her goodbye and driving away. Pretending none of this had ever happened. To her, this was playful. A fun extension of the games we had been playing. To me, it was a door swinging open on something I could never unsee. I had already accepted I was a cuckold. I enjoyed watching Mark fuck my wife. I enjoyed kneeling for him, tasting him, swallowing him. I enjoyed the way he took control of both of us. But this next step… letting him inside me… letting him turn me into something else… that would rewrite me. I knew it in my bones.
Still. Trying it on couldn’t hurt. Just to see. Just to know what it looked like.
I stood up, took the panties first. Soft pink lace, high-cut legs, a tiny satin bow at the front. I stepped into them, pulled them up. My cock was still semi-hard; I tucked it to the side, nestling it against my hip. I turned sideways in the mirror. My ass looked… incredible. The lace framed the cheeks perfectly, making them pop, giving me the illusion of hips I had never noticed before. The fabric hugged the curves, accentuating the roundness, the softness. I looked like I belonged in them.
Next the camisole top. Thin straps, sheer over the chest, satin panels that draped softly. I slipped it over my head. No breasts to fill it out, but the way it clung to my soft chest, the gentle swell of my belly, the narrow waist… it looked feminine. Delicate. Pretty. My thick, bushy hair framed my face in a way that suddenly seemed less rugged, more… inviting. Mark was going to love this. The thought sent a warm rush through me. Pride. Happiness that I could please him. Had I already made the decision? Then I realized there really was no decision. This was just going to happen.
Cindi knocked again. “Okay, I’m coming in now.”
The door opened. She stepped inside, eyes widening as she took me in from head to toe. A slow, delighted smile spread across her face. “You look gorgeous, love.”
She held a small makeup bag in one hand. “Sit,” she said, pointing to the closed toilet lid.
I obeyed. She stood between my knees, close enough that I could smell her perfume, light and floral. First she worked on my hair. She teased it out with gentle fingers, lifting the roots, fluffing the waves until it looked full and soft and womanly. She ran a brush through it, smoothing the flyaways, letting it fall in soft layers around my face. Then she took a razor and shaving cream from the bag. She lathered my legs, underarms, chest, even the faint trail below my navel. She shaved me smooth, careful and thorough, wiping away every trace of hair until my skin felt silky and exposed. She painted my fingernails and toenails a soft coral pink, blowing gently on each one to dry it faster.
Then she turned to my face. Foundation first, blended carefully to even my skin tone. Concealer under my eyes. A light dusting of powder to set it. She shaped my eyebrows with a tiny pair of tweezers, plucking stray hairs until they arched softly. Eyeliner next, a thin black line that made my eyes look bigger, darker. Mascara, two coats, lengthening my lashes until they looked impossibly long. Blush, just a hint on the apples of my cheeks. Finally, lipstick. Light pink, glossy, applied with a small brush. She stepped back, tilted my chin from side to side, studying her work with a critical eye. Then she smiled, wide and proud.
“Have a look, my dear,” she said. “You are absolutely lovely.”
I stood slowly. Turned to the mirror.
I didn’t recognize the person staring back.
She was beautiful.
Soft features framed by full, fluffy hair. Big eyes lined in black, lashes dark and sweeping. Cheeks flushed pink, lips glossy and inviting. The nightgown clung to my curves in all the right places, the satin shimmering under the light, the lace panties peeking beneath the short hem. My ass looked round and perky, my waist looked smaller, my legs looked longer and smoother. Even without breasts, the shape was unmistakably feminine. I turned sideways, then all the way around, admiring the way the fabric moved with me. I posed, one hand on my hip, lips parted slightly. I tried a sultry look, then a shy one. I smiled at myself in the mirror and watched her smile back.
I was amazed. It was like discovering a new person who had been living inside me all along, waiting for permission to come out. I wondered why I had ever considered leaving her trapped. There was no decision left to make. She was already here.
I admired her in the mirror for a long minute, turning, posing, practicing different expressions. Wondering what her name should be. Dara? Daria? Erica? Something soft and pretty. I didn’t know yet. But I couldn’t wait to find out. I couldn’t wait to discover everything about her there was to know. Because I wasn’t her yet. Not completely. This beautiful woman looking back at me wasn’t fully me, at least not yet. But I wanted her to be. I wanted to become her.
And I knew Mark was going to help make that happen.
Cindi stepped behind me, hands on my shoulders, meeting my eyes in the reflection. “You ready to show him?” she asked softly.
I nodded, heart pounding with a mix of fear and exhilaration.
She kissed the side of my neck. “Then let’s go, beautiful.”
I took one last look at the woman in the mirror, smiled at her, and followed Cindi out of the bathroom. The nightgown swished against my thighs with every step. My ass swayed naturally in the lace panties. My painted toes peeked out beneath the hem. I felt exposed, vulnerable, and strangely powerful.
Mark was waiting in the living room.
And I couldn’t wait for him to see what I had become.
The Discovery
I walked out to the living room, swaying my hips in an exaggerated, practiced way that felt both awkward and thrilling at the same time. Each step made the short pink nightgown swish against my smooth thighs, the satin cool and slippery. I had been practicing the walk in front of the bathroom mirror for the last few minutes, trying to roll my hips like I had seen women do in movies, letting my ass move naturally instead of fighting it. The lace panties hugged me tightly, the fabric riding up between my cheeks with every sway. I felt exposed, ridiculous, and strangely powerful all at once.
I also experimented with my voice. I softened it, raised the pitch just enough, let it come from higher in my throat instead of my chest. “Hi Mark,” I said shyly, testing the sound. In my head it came out delicate, breathy, really good. Feminine.
Mark looked up from the couch. His eyes widened instantly. He stood up so fast the cushions shifted. “WOW!” he said, voice deep and surprised. “Who are you?”
I stopped a few feet away, hands clasped in front of me, suddenly shy again. “I don’t know,” I answered in that even softer voice, letting it tremble just a little.
Mark glanced over at Cindi, who was leaning against the doorway watching with a proud smile, then back at me. “I think I’m looking at two of the prettiest girls I have ever seen in my life.”
He walked toward me slowly, towering over me even more now that I was barefoot and dressed like this. I had to tilt my head way back to meet his eyes. He reached out and placed both hands gently on my exposed shoulders, thumbs brushing the thin straps of the camisole. His touch was warm, firm, grounding.
“I’m going to call you Erica,” he said decisively.
The name settled over me like warm water. It wasn’t just the compliment, although hearing him say I looked pretty sent heat rushing through my chest. It was him giving me the name. Claiming it. Naming me. He barely had to touch me and he was already turning me into her. Erica. The name I had been circling in my mind without daring to say out loud. It felt right. It felt like the beginning of something I could never undo. And there was so much more coming. That was the terrifying part. Erica was about to be born into the world, and it was not going to be painless.
We gazed into each other’s eyes. This time I knew he was going to kiss me. He bent his head slowly, giving me time to pull away if I wanted. I didn’t. His lips brushed mine softly once, twice. Then he sucked gently on my lower lip, tugging it between his teeth for a heartbeat before releasing. The next kiss his tongue grazed mine, just the tip, sending electricity shooting down my spine. I leaked into the panties immediately, a warm trickle soaking the lace. His kisses deepened. Tongues met fully, sliding together, exploring. His hands traced down my back, slow and deliberate, until they reached my ass. He squeezed both cheeks firmly through the satin, kneading the soft flesh. Then he slid his palms lower, to my upper thighs, and lifted me effortlessly.
My legs wrapped around his waist on instinct. My arms folded behind his neck, fingers lacing together. Our bodies pressed tight. His chest against the thin camisole, my soft belly against his hard stomach, my leaking cock trapped between us in the soaked panties. We kissed for what felt like forever. Deep, hungry kisses. Slow, wet ones. I didn’t want it to end. The feeling was incredible, transforming. Like my whole body was waking up in a new way.
Finally he set me down on the couch, gentle but firm. I sat with my legs slightly parted, nightgown riding up my thighs. Mark knelt in front of me. He hooked his fingers into the waistband of my panties and pulled them down slowly, peeling the wet lace away from my skin. My cock sprang free, semi-hard and glistening with pre-cum. He kissed the inside of my thighs, soft open-mouthed kisses that trailed higher and higher. Then he lifted my legs under the knees, draping them over his broad shoulders. My ass lifted off the cushion slightly.
He started licking my crack. Slow, wet, grazing licks that made me shiver. Each pass of his tongue felt deliberate, teasing, like he was treating me like I had a pussy instead of an asshole. He circled the tight ring with the flat of his tongue, then pushed the tip inside. Gentle at first, then deeper. Gratuitous, swirling licks inside my hole. The sensation was wonderful, warm and wet and intimate. I lay back against the cushions, legs over his shoulders, hands gripping the fabric beside me. This big, rough, strong man was being so gentle, so careful with me while I was dressed like this, looking like this. He really was making me feel like I was a woman in his mind. Not too long ago, Mark was pressing my face in the carpet and painting my ass crack with cum. Now he’s treating me like a princess. He made me feel protected and loved.
When he finally pulled back, he noticed the big puddle of pre-cum that had leaked from my semi-hard dick onto my belly. My erection had started to soften while his tongue was pressing into me. Maybe my body was responding to the realization that I wasn’t really a man anymore. I wasn’t concerned. In fact, the thought of my dick shrinking, retreating, becoming something else to please him made my arousal spike higher than it had ever been.
Mark rubbed his middle finger through the puddle on my belly, coating it thickly. Then he brought it to my asshole and started to press in. At first it was pleasant, a gentle stretch, warm and slick from my own pre-cum. Past the first knuckle, though, I tensed. Panic flickered through me. Mark noticed immediately. He put his other hand on top of my soft penis and rubbed it in slow circles, soothing, coaxing. It didn’t relax me completely, but it did make me want more of that finger. He worked it in and out gently, watching my face the whole time, careful not to hurt me. When he finally got it deep enough, he curled it and rubbed my prostate.
My dick turned into a soft, leaky faucet. A different kind of orgasm started building. Not the sharp, explosive kind I was used to. This was deeper, more diffuse, almost uncomfortable in its intensity but incredible at the same time. Waves of pleasure rolled through me without a hard release. I moaned, high and breathy, hips rocking against his hand.
“I don’t think he can take your cock, Mark,” Cindi said from the side, voice worried. She had been watching quietly, enjoying the show, but now concern creased her brow.
Mark looked at her calmly. “Trust me, Baby. She was made for this.” Then he looked down at me, eyes dark and sure. “Isn’t that right, my sweet little princess? You were made for this.” He leaned over me and kissed me again, slow and deep. “It’s not going to be easy, Sweetie, but you want to feel my cock in you more than anything you’ve ever wanted, don’t you?”
I looked up at him with wide, wanting eyes. I nodded. In a breathy, trembling voice I said, “Yes. I want your cock inside me.”
Mark gently pulled the camisole off over my head, leaving me completely naked except for the makeup and painted nails. He leaned up and rubbed his cock through the drippy mess on my belly and crotch. There was no need for extra lube. I was making plenty. Cindi helped, scooping the slick pre-cum with her fingers and spreading it over his shaft, then rubbing more around my hole.
The fear hit hard when he pressed the head against me. This is crazy. There is no way this is going to work. But I trusted him. I needed it. He pushed a little more. I put my hand against the front of his hip, as if I could slow him or control it somehow. He pushed again. My body resisted instinctively.
“Breathe,” Mark said softly. “In and out. Relax. That’s a good girl, Erica.”
Hearing him say my name, my new name, made me relax just enough. It distracted me from the stretch. He pushed a little more. The head popped in. He was inside me. That part wasn’t so bad. He pressed further. The pain intensified, sharp and burning. I remembered college anatomy class. Outer sphincter. Inner sphincter. He was past the first. Working on the second. The pain was too much. It felt like I was going to rip, like my insides were getting destroyed.
“Wait!” I screamed. “I can’t. I can’t. It hurts too much.” Tears welled up in my eyes. I saw matching tears in Cindi’s as she watched from the side.
“You can do it, Princess,” Mark said gently. “We’ll go slower. You want to belong to me, don’t you, Erica?”
I was sobbing now, chest heaving, but I nodded yes. I didn’t know if I could take the pain, but I knew I had to. This wasn’t about sex and pleasure anymore. It was about becoming who I was meant to be. Mark understood that. I could see it in his eyes. He wasn’t just trying to fuck me. He was guiding me through my journey. He pressed in a little more. So slow it felt like forever. I kept wondering if he was all the way in yet. But it wasn’t. There was always more. More cock. More pain.
When the thickest part reached my inner sphincter I thought I might pass out. I was sobbing and breathing rapidly. Mark had a way to help me through this last part of the pain. He placed both hands around my throat, not choking, just pressing enough to slow the blood flow. He was in control of my life now, but I trusted him. Stars danced at the edges of my vision. Then everything went soft and hazy. I don’t think I passed out, but I definitely faded for a minute.
The next thing I knew was feeling Mark’s hands on my chest and his balls pressed tightly against my ass. He was all the way in. Finally! I felt so full. So fulfilled. He stayed still, letting me adjust, his huge cock resting deep inside me. My body was molding around it. His eyes looked into mine. He was smiling, proud. There was still pain, but my body was already accommodating him, softening around him, accepting him as part of me. Being connected to him like that felt worth every second of the hurt.
He leaned down and kissed me again, deeply and passionately, while his manhood throbbed inside me. The joy was indescribable. I could have stayed like that forever.
But his cock wasn’t as patient. I felt it twitch. It took so long to stretch out my hole and now he was ready to fuck me. I was ready too.
He started stroking in and out slowly. Lifted up slightly and spit on my balls so it would run down into my crack for extra lubrication. There was still friction, a little pain, but nothing like before. Nothing I couldn’t handle. Nothing that would stop me from enjoying the new feelings flooding through me.
Mark lay on top of me fully, his weight pressing me into the cushions. He kissed me while he pumped faster. I loved being trapped under his big body as his cock slid in and out, raking across my prostate with every stroke. My soft dick was squashed between us, leaking steadily. The sensation was strange and perfect. It felt like time had slowed down, like every thrust lasted minutes.
He started kissing and sucking on my neck as his strokes grew faster. I forgot about the pain entirely. A strong tingling built in my groin, different from anything I had felt before. I wasn’t sure how I could orgasm with my dick still soft and trapped, but it was happening anyway. Like my cock had become a clit, teased and rubbed by his body.
“Are you ready for me to fill you with my cum, baby?” he growled in my ear.
That was all it took. The electric feelings peaked. My body convulsed. I grabbed his big arms, gripping as tight as I could. Stars burst behind my eyes again. My balls twitched. Hot streams of cum shot out of my soft little dick, making a warm, slippery pool between our bodies.
“YES!” I screamed in a high voice I barely recognized. “Yes, please! Cum inside me!”
Mark pounded harder, so hard I thought I might break. I was getting fucked so good, by a real man. All the times I watched Cindi get fucked, I didn’t want to admit that I secretly wanted to be her. Now it was happening, better than I imagined it could be. I reached down and grabbed his ass cheeks with both hands, grinding my soft dick into his stomach. My orgasm kept going, more intense than anything I had ever felt. It felt like I was cumming for the first time. I was cumming for the first time as a woman.
Mark growled loudly into my ear and pressed deep, burying himself completely. Then he made a long, slow, loud groan of release as his cock started shooting thick streams of cum into my bowels, into my soul.
“Fuck, yes!” he moaned in his deep powerful voice.
I couldn’t taste it this time, but I felt his essence more intensely than ever before. It changed me. Took me over. Replaced everything I ever thought about myself with pure desire. My mind went blank except for thoughts of pleasing him, taking his cock, taking his cum. I felt like I could sense the chemical and psychological changes taking place in me, his foreign hormones seeping deeper, rewriting me, softening the sharp edges of my masculinity like wax under slow heat until it melted away.
He held me tight and kissed me again. His cock was still pulsing, or maybe it was my asshole throbbing around him. I could feel my heartbeat in my stretched hole. Then he looked into my eyes and said, “Wow, you feel amazing, Erica. How are you feeling? Did you like that? Do you feel different?”
I didn’t have words. I reached up, pulled his head down, and kissed him again. He smiled, understanding.
After a few minutes of soft kissing, Mark leaned up and started pulling out slowly. I felt sad as his cock left my body. Then I felt his cum dripping steadily out of me. I wondered how much of it my body had already absorbed. Enough, I thought. Because I felt drastically changed. My thoughts drifted toward a strange, yielding calm I had never known before, and in the quiet afterglow I noticed Mark just staring at me.
“She still looks good with her makeup all smudged and her hair all messy, doesn’t she?” Mark said to Cindi.
“She sure does,” Cindi answered. “We call that the fucked-hard makeover.”
We all laughed, soft and tired, but I was still in the moment.
“I hope you liked that enough to want to do it again, sometimes,” Mark said to me.
I smiled, still breathless. “How about now?”
Cindi cut in quickly. “Easy there, lovers. You two need a break. Don’t break our new toy the first night, Mark, or I won’t let you come and play with her again.”
We laughed again, but a serious thought settled deep in my mind. Mark could come play with me whenever he wanted. He didn’t have to ask Cindi. He didn’t even have to ask me. I belonged to him now. He was part of me.
Cindi helped me back into the camisole. She fixed my makeup and hair with gentle touches. We sat around on the couch for a while, talking softly, laughing. Then Cindi and I took turns sucking Mark while the other licked his ass. Then there was more fucking. Positions changed. Mouths and hands and bodies everywhere. It went on until well after the sun came up the next day. When we were finally exhausted, Cindi and I wrapped ourselves around either side of Mark, nestled on his chest, with big arms pulling us close. The comfort and connection I felt was euphoric. My ass was so sore and my body was spent, but if he wanted me again I wouldn’t have hesitated. I belonged to him in that way. I would give him anything he desired, anything a woman could give him. I couldn’t give him a baby, but I could raise his babies and love them as my own. I was probably raising one already, and after last night there might be another on the way. I couldn’t be happier. Cindi looked at me and smiled, across his wide chest. She touched my hand that was resting there. She could sense my happiness and contentment.
I didn’t know what would happen to my normal life after that. I wasn’t anxious about it, though. I was excited. I knew who I was now. I knew my place. Cindi and I would be soulmates forever, whether I was Derek or Erica. There were just things I could never give her. Things men like Mark could give her. Things she needed. The same things I needed.
Cindi probably knew about Erica long before I did. She had been hiding inside me for years. I just hadn’t known she was there. I was so happy to finally discover her. To let her out. To become her. To become his.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.